Ceramic apex seal clearance.
#13
Originally Posted by 1Revvin7' post='923858' date='Jul 3 2009, 02:08 PM
I have tried .004/5/6 and Pete is right.. I wish someone would have told me that back then
Would have saved me a few bucks and endless hours of time...
Would have saved me a few bucks and endless hours of time...
Ditto.
I have a production line of brand new "clone" RR 13B-REW's that I do for people all around the world and when I saw the result of the 2 piece V's 1 piece it simply shocked me. I could feel the difference simply turning the engine by hand off the stand
To put numbers to it. Two seal designs (same end clearance)
100psi one piece
125psi two piece
When I use up my last 4 sets of one piece ceramic apex seals in customer jobs I will only specify 2 piece for any future specification engines that have my name on them. Some people do want the one piece as 13BT-RX3 for various reasons which are legitimate.... at the end of the day its a pure price point thing as the multi piece construction in full ceramic is prohibitive for most people anyway. hahaha even ANY ceramic people bitch and moan about the costs
#14
Originally Posted by RICE RACING' post='923876' date='Jul 4 2009, 06:49 AM
Ditto.
I have a production line of brand new "clone" RR 13B-REW's that I do for people all around the world and when I saw the result of the 2 piece V's 1 piece it simply shocked me. I could feel the difference simply turning the engine by hand off the stand
To put numbers to it. Two seal designs (same end clearance)
100psi one piece
125psi two piece
When I use up my last 4 sets of one piece ceramic apex seals in customer jobs I will only specify 2 piece for any future specification engines that have my name on them. Some people do want the one piece as 13BT-RX3 for various reasons which are legitimate.... at the end of the day its a pure price point thing as the multi piece construction in full ceramic is prohibitive for most people anyway. hahaha even ANY ceramic people bitch and moan about the costs
I have a production line of brand new "clone" RR 13B-REW's that I do for people all around the world and when I saw the result of the 2 piece V's 1 piece it simply shocked me. I could feel the difference simply turning the engine by hand off the stand
To put numbers to it. Two seal designs (same end clearance)
100psi one piece
125psi two piece
When I use up my last 4 sets of one piece ceramic apex seals in customer jobs I will only specify 2 piece for any future specification engines that have my name on them. Some people do want the one piece as 13BT-RX3 for various reasons which are legitimate.... at the end of the day its a pure price point thing as the multi piece construction in full ceramic is prohibitive for most people anyway. hahaha even ANY ceramic people bitch and moan about the costs
How far have you pushed the two piece seals?
#15
Originally Posted by 13BT-RX3' post='923879' date='Jul 4 2009, 07:26 AM
How far have you pushed the two piece seals?
They take as much power as the one piece design, in my view they are actually stronger
The only one I ever had fail *during detonation* cracked on the one piece end and not on the other side as would most would think.
If you can stretch the budget then 2 piece is the only way to go
#16
Originally Posted by 13BT-RX3' post='923867' date='Jul 4 2009, 12:00 AM
I am willing to sacrifice 5% power for a motor that will live with a little abuse. I would rather loose a little than have a catastrophic failure. Thanks for the input guys.
Its more than 5% power..
#17
Originally Posted by 1Revvin7' post='923902' date='Jul 4 2009, 09:32 PM
Its more than 5% power..
What is? From .004-.006, from .0015-.006? If the NRS come with .0055 clearance how can you have data with less clearance. I am running a very high overlap motor so the cylinder pressure is lower at cranking RPMs. I was getting 90psi on all faces, if Peter was getting 100 PSI with the one piece seals that sounds like a very small loss. I have heard stories of cars that wouldn't even start under their own starting system making well over 800 HP. In my case i am not asking about a street driven car, i am asking about a 900+ HP methanol engine that will never drop below 7000rpm from the start.
Thanks to the people contributing!
#18
Yeah it's single digit power loss, I have seen around 8% to 9% personally which is quite large .
My typical engines (porting as on my site) on one piece NRS apex seal will do 95psi to 100psi range (as new or 100% new motor) the exact same porting and mechanical specification with the 2 piece apex seal will do 125psi+ (have had higher figures of 130 to 135+psi) it is a massive difference in compression. I have one customer who circuit races and he too reported the highest ever compression on his full bridge port N/A motors when switching to the 2 piece.
I had another who only a few days ago switch over back to steel two piece type from one piece NRS (crack 2 seals from over boosting but with no further engine damage) and he reported a gain in HP and easier starting.
Can't type strongly enough that there is for sure negative effects of low cranking compression going through to power at 7,8,9,10 thousand rpm. I personally have seen one car that I controlled all variables on which dropped 15psi cranking pressure and it went from 430rwkw region to high 390rwkw consistently with all same parameters. This motor was border line and could start with (tested at 600m altitude) 80psi cranking but below 65psi did not really want to do it once warm.
If the apex seal end clearance or construction mean you will loose a fair bit, then so long as you know the negatives then you can make a correct choice for you
My typical engines (porting as on my site) on one piece NRS apex seal will do 95psi to 100psi range (as new or 100% new motor) the exact same porting and mechanical specification with the 2 piece apex seal will do 125psi+ (have had higher figures of 130 to 135+psi) it is a massive difference in compression. I have one customer who circuit races and he too reported the highest ever compression on his full bridge port N/A motors when switching to the 2 piece.
I had another who only a few days ago switch over back to steel two piece type from one piece NRS (crack 2 seals from over boosting but with no further engine damage) and he reported a gain in HP and easier starting.
Can't type strongly enough that there is for sure negative effects of low cranking compression going through to power at 7,8,9,10 thousand rpm. I personally have seen one car that I controlled all variables on which dropped 15psi cranking pressure and it went from 430rwkw region to high 390rwkw consistently with all same parameters. This motor was border line and could start with (tested at 600m altitude) 80psi cranking but below 65psi did not really want to do it once warm.
If the apex seal end clearance or construction mean you will loose a fair bit, then so long as you know the negatives then you can make a correct choice for you
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
-xlr8planet-
Rotary Engine Building, Porting & Swaps
5
12-28-2008 11:51 AM
White_FC
Rotary Engine Building, Porting & Swaps
4
03-11-2004 10:45 PM
Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)