s3 vs s4/s5
here are some of the differences and "my opinions" on if they are better or not ...
S3 has 3 mm apex seals - honestly, i don't care about 2 vs. 3. both have been more than strong enough for the engines i've built.
S5 has 9.7:1 compression vs the 9.4:1 of S3 and S4 - that's an advantage as long as you stay normally aspirated, but it's not something that i would lose sleep over for all but the most extreme racing purposes.
S5 has lighter rotating assembly - advantage again, but again, i wouldn't lose sleep over it.
S4 and S5 have better intakes and 4 injectors - that's an advantage and i think it is worth getting the best one you can find if (and only if you have no intentions) of going with a custom setup like i'm building.
all 3 13B models lend themselves to relatively easy conversion to 4-port motors. you'll just need a decent 12A or 13B-T block to do so.
of course, there is the water seal placement and i've read that the S4/S5 placement in the side housings is an advantage, but i don't really have an opinion.
that's about all i can think of readily.
hope it helps a little.
S3 has 3 mm apex seals - honestly, i don't care about 2 vs. 3. both have been more than strong enough for the engines i've built.
S5 has 9.7:1 compression vs the 9.4:1 of S3 and S4 - that's an advantage as long as you stay normally aspirated, but it's not something that i would lose sleep over for all but the most extreme racing purposes.
S5 has lighter rotating assembly - advantage again, but again, i wouldn't lose sleep over it.
S4 and S5 have better intakes and 4 injectors - that's an advantage and i think it is worth getting the best one you can find if (and only if you have no intentions) of going with a custom setup like i'm building.
all 3 13B models lend themselves to relatively easy conversion to 4-port motors. you'll just need a decent 12A or 13B-T block to do so.
of course, there is the water seal placement and i've read that the S4/S5 placement in the side housings is an advantage, but i don't really have an opinion.
that's about all i can think of readily.
hope it helps a little.
Originally Posted by diabolical1' post='839855' date='Oct 6 2006, 09:20 AM
of course, there is the water seal placement and i've read that the S4/S5 placement in the side housings is an advantage, but i don't really have an opinion.
that's about all i can think of readily.
hope it helps a little.
Are they s5/s5 plates really an advantage. I thought that the water seal placement on the s4/s5 was a disadvantage because the water seals are on the plates instead of the rotor housing. Therefore making the lapping procedure an issue because you can only lap s4/s5 plates so many times before they water seal dosn't seal anymore because the grove isn't deep enough?
Originally Posted by 13bdatsun510' post='840853' date='Oct 14 2006, 06:34 AM
Are they s5/s5 plates really an advantage. I thought that the water seal placement on the s4/s5 was a disadvantage because the water seals are on the plates instead of the rotor housing. Therefore making the lapping procedure an issue because you can only lap s4/s5 plates so many times before they water seal dosn't seal anymore because the grove isn't deep enough?
the s4/5 plates have larger ports stock, and are lighter casting, but i like the water seal in the rotor housing....
Originally Posted by 13bdatsun510' post='840853' date='Oct 14 2006, 05:34 AM
I thought that the water seal placement on the s4/s5 was a disadvantage because the water seals are on the plates instead of the rotor housing. Therefore making the lapping procedure an issue because you can only lap s4/s5 plates so many times before they water seal dosn't seal anymore because the grove isn't deep enough?
an interesting thing that i've read about is using the 86+ side housings with pre-86 rotor housings and doubling up on the water seals. it may be worth some research for those of you that want bigger numbers for bragging rights. personally, i don't go for stuff like that simply because the motors i've built up to this point were mainly for the street and i was not willing to try some things just for the possibility of a few more HP.


